Bigger homer: Jack Edwards or Tommy Heinshohn?


 

I hate politics. I was watching the Bruins last night, who were losing 3-0 to the Rangers. I decided to do my civic duty and watch President Obama’s State of the Union address, since the game seemed to be a downer. Through the magic of Facebook I found out that I missed one of the great comebacks in recent Bruin memory. Down by 3 goals with 10 minutes to go the Bruins scored once, and then pulled Tuukka Rask in the final 2 minutes, scoring twice!! Thank God for DVR.

maroney-boehner

The Bruins ended up losing in a shootout, but I came out of it even more optimistic about this teams chance to win its 2nd Stanley Cup Title in 3 years. I also came out if with these 3 thoughts:

 

1) Rick Nash is the most talented player in the NHL. I’ve never seen anyone with his size who is able to do the things he does.

rangers-bruins-4_3_r536_c534

2) Brad Marchand is the best player on the Bruins. He’s going to have a better career than Tyler Seguin. You heard it here first.

 

Marsh-mont

Marsh-mont

3) Jack Edwards may be a huge homer, but he is the friggin man!!

 

The final thought got me thinking, which announcer is the bigger homer; Jack Edwards or Tommy Heinsohn. Here is the case for each:

Jack Edwards

 images-30

Last night’s game against the Rangers was Jack Edwards at his finest. After witnessing one of the greatest comebacks any of us has ever seen Jack literally started jumping for joy in the booth. Realizing that people would point out his unrestrained behavior and point out his unhidden Bruins-bias he responded by saying “People will say oh he’s such a homahhh, he’s such a homahhh. Get OVER IT!! You come to hockey games to get excited”.

Fans and writers of other teams can’t stand Edwards. For the most part we love him around here. Some find him a little over the top, but I love this guy’s enthusiasm. He’s a true fan, he’s well spoken, and he comes up with some of the most outrageous proverbs that you couldn’t find inside your fortune cookie.

Jack has done a number of things over the years to establish himself as the ultimate homer, and master of the one-liners.

  • “Orpik threw Daniel Paille like he was a kids teddy bear flying across a bedroom”
  • “One, two, three, D’oh”
  • “On Donder, On Blitzen, On Seidenberg!!”
  • “This……is……a…….SKUNKING!!!”
  • “A Johnny Rocket!!”
  • “Lucic gives Spezza a little tap, as if to say the Golf Course it that way”
  • “That was a Matt Cooke sandwich. Wasn’t very tasty I might add”
  • “If you’re waiting for Tuukka Rask to move first, you’re going to grow old doing it”
  • “It’s beat up David Krecji day”
  • “Thornton comes over and says ‘if you wanna go, I’m the guy, 22 is the address’”
  • “2 U’s, 2 K’s, 2 points” (after Tuukka Rask wins)

120308_johnny-boychuk-johnny-rocket-goal__getty

“Niskanen is getting his head rearranged by Sheriff Shane Hnidy. He is not gonna be a pretty looking boy anymore.”

  • “They have beaten them, and tonight they have beaten them up”
  • “Daniel Sedin, with a chicken wing on Sedin’s stick”
  • “Concuss THAT”

 

Who can forget Jack’s jingoistic rant after defeating the Canadiens on Patriot’s Day:

  • “234 years ago, a bunch of ragtag farmers stood up against the greatest fighting force in the world. Well, a bunch of modern day Bostonians have turned back hockey’s royalty, and they have sent the Montreal faithful on a redcoated retreat to the exits!!”

Or his rant after sweeping the Flyers in the 2nd round of the playoffs:

  • “SUMMERTIME is coming to Philadelphia!!!”

lucic_620-thumb-620xauto-95470

Or his wild explosion in anger when Roman Hamrlik flopped after a hit by Michael Ryder:

  • “Hamrlik goes down like he was shot. GGGEEETTTT UPPPPPPPP!!!!!”

I have no idea where he comes up this stuff, but I know he’s just going to keep it coming. Oh yea and Canadiens fans hate him with a passion. Even more reason to like what he brings to the table!

 

 

Tommy Heinsohn

 images-31

Tommy brings a different style to the Celtics. Jack was originally an ESPN guy. They only hire guys with neutral accents that speak well and eloquently. Tommy works for NESN and it doesn’t take listeners long to figure out that he is not ESPN material. There are several reasons Tommy can only be a local network commentator. He’s got a thick accent that’s a blend of Jersey, Boston and Pumba from the Lion King. He is unapologetically pro-Celtic. He notoriously gives out “Tommy Points” to players that hustle. And he likes to YELL!!!!

images-32

The most common object of Tommy’s ire is the referees. Quite often Tommy disagrees with their in-game calls. I feel his pain a lot of the time, because NBA refs are a disgrace to humanity. I love when you know a Tommy blowup is coming. You see a bad call and a brief silence, followed by something light from Mike Gorman. You can hear Tommy breathing in. Then right before the replay Tommy just lets it out. Usually his volume escalates as the replay continues, and he closes it out with something like “Boy I tell you, these referees are out to lunch”. I love Tommy because he’s like the crazy stubborn grandfather who’s never been wrong his entire life. Never.

BDD_lottery_5.23.07_gett

My favorite is when Tommy initially complains about a call, and upon seeing the replay realizes the call was good. Usually Mike Gorman says something like “Yup. That was a foul. Good call”. This is the only time you won’t hear from Tommy during a game.

EP_235_STILLS_-67-300x168

Here’s some great Tommy Rants (all in one game):

  • “HE WALKED!!! HE WALKED!!!! What is WRONG WITH THESE GUYS???!!!”
  • “They’re gonna call it a hard foul. THEY’RE GONNA HAVE A HARD FOUL!!!!! These guys are RIDICULOUS!!!! These guys ARE RIDICULOUS”
  • “Aw give me a break. They’re gonna call hand checking now? This Kenny Mauer needs to go home to his wife. Because no one here loves him”
  • “Yea I’ll tell you what I said to the official afterwards. Worst officiated game I’ve seen all year. And you know what he said to me in a very smug fashion? Merry Christmas. You don’t know how smug these guys can be. They’re awful”

 

  • “If you’re 7 feet tall, and you don’t speak English, come to Dallas. They’re hiring”
  • “These officials are going for every, every God damn flop”
  • “Danny Ferry went to Duke. My kid went to Duke. I’m so fired up I may never talk to my kid again”

 

He also thinks every player on the Celtics will eventually be the greatest player to ever live by the time they retire. For instance, here are his thoughts on the legendary Greg Stiemsma:

  • “His timing and how he goes around blocking shots, reminds me of Bill Russell”.

images-33

However, Steimsma can never compare to the Greatest Celtic player of all time….. Walter McCarty. “I LOVE WATAH!!!!!!”

So who is the bigger homer of the 2? It’s a really tough call. Best answer in the comments gets featured in the next blog.

Share this on Facebook or Twitter if you like it and want to spread the good word. Hit follow in the bottom right to subscribe. Follow me on twitter @aidanfromworc

12 thoughts on “Bigger homer: Jack Edwards or Tommy Heinshohn?

  1. Kristie

    I love Tommy Heinsohn; he’s been a Celtic for over 50 years and truly defines ‘bleeding green.’ Aside from being knowledgable, he’s always good for a laugh- like when he gave KG the Tommy Award “for not falling over” after playing 47 minutes in one game last week. Listening to Tommy beats listening to that fucknut Marv Alberts any day of the week!

    Reply
      1. SUL

        You Like Joe Buck???? O man, thats a tough one to handle. To amend my earlier comments. Tommy Heinsohn was today nominated for the NBA Hall of Fame. No not for the first time as he’s already in the hall of fame, but for the second time as a coach and I wouldn’t be surprised if he one day goes in for broadcasting.
        Additionally how can you not like Jeff Van Gundy, best bball anouncer around, hes by partisan for the most part, knowledgeable, hates the refs and has one hell of a funny Espn Commercial.

        Reply
    1. Galina

      Happy New Year dear Dragonstar, and to all your readers – I am lkoniog forward to se you and many other “Blog-friends” on this site during 2011 – Thank you for keeping this blog alive !!!

      Reply
  2. Go UMass

    Is this a transcript of Wednesdays Felger and Mazz…?

    Anyway. Tommy is the bigger homer by far, mostly for the reasons given by SUL. He played for, coached and announced the C’s. The Celtics and Massachusetts has been his life (Holy Cross grad). I think he might literally bleed Celtic green.

    Jack on the other hand is a trained sports announcer. Although he clearly favors the B’s I would expect nothing less from the home town announcer. My problem with Jack is for every “GET UP” you get a head scratching “it’s like a two by four being split by a hammer”. I liked “Snow ball 1 Hell 0″ but “he was the peanut butter in an ugly sandwich” is stupid. I feel like Jack has a notebook of stupid shit to say. Tommy’s rage comes naturally like a true Boston fan.

    To be honest I enjoy when NBC has the Bruins and Doc Emerick does the games. He has a great distinctive voice that keeps you on the edge of your seat and doesn’t muck up games with Lake Guchigawa or whatever references.

    Reply
    1. Aidan Kearney (@aidanfromworc)

      LOL Felger and Mazz got me thinking about it for sure, but they were mainly talking Edwards. A lot of what Jack says is scripted for sure, but some of that stuff is just priceless. “Summertime in Philadelphia” is just fantastic. My personal favorite is “22 is the address”. You’re right though, “concuss that” is stretching it. The one comment where he did over an objective opinion was “It’s beat up David Krecji day”. Krecji is soft as poo. I’m honestly surprised Edwards hasn’t come up with something like “You better Czech yourself before hitting David Krecji”. That’s gotta be coming up soon.

      Reply
  3. Charles

    Tommy Heinsohn played his entire career with the Celtics, won a bunch of titles, then coached the team for eight years and won a few more. He’s never worked for another NBA team. Why would he be a fan of anyone else? He’s not coaching or scouting, so why would you want him to be objective?

    Reply
    1. Flaca

      sunshine,^^”人生得一知己, 死而无憾.”Yes.And, if you come to HK, just leave your contact no. here, I’ll bring you to enjoy the deiluiocs HK Chinese Cuinese! Yum yum!!!!

      Reply
  4. SUL

    I absolutely love that you wrote about this topic. As I was watching the game last night I couldn’t help but think how much of a homer Jack Edwards is, and then started to think that Bruins fans biggest argument against the Celtics is that Green Teamers are homers, and Tommy Heinsohn is too, blah blah blah. Well my feeling is that yes both are homers, but Edwards is a much bigger offender. He never has anything good to say about opposing players. We could be playing Mother Teresa and he would make her into a whore. Any player that fights a Bruin is a hooligan, and bruins are always in the right.
    In Heinsohn’s case he played for, coached and now announces for the Celtics. He has credibility in his extensive knowledge of the game. He hates on the refs, and rightfully so. He is a massive homer, and over rates every Celtics player, you’d think Steimsa was Bill Russell if you never saw him. However Heinsohn will give credit on occasion to opposing players and coaches.

    Both men openly admit their love and being “homers” for their respective franchises. I say Edwards is the bigger Homer, even though Bruins fans will never admit this because he is “funny”. Well to that I say at least Heinshon has a reason to be a homer, winning 2 championships with the celtics, coaching the team and now being a broadcaster.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s